Rating: 2/5
Review:
Disappointing
Piers Paul Read's books passed me by the first time around
so I was glad to have an opportunity to try one, but although The Villa
Golitsyn began rather well, I wasn't very keen overall.
First published in 1981 and set in 1979, the book begins with
a good espionage thriller set-up as Simon Milson, a middle-ranking civil
servant in the Foreign Service is sent to Nice to stay with Willy, an old
school friend whom he has not seen for years, in order to determine whether the
friend was responsible for passing secrets to the enemy fifteen years ago. From here on, it is largely a novel of
character as the various, slightly oddly assorted, guests interact with Willy
and, to some extent, each other. There
is a convincing picture of an intelligent, charismatic man disintegrating in
alcoholism, with some interesting, if a little clunky, discussions of morals,
ethics and so on.
It's decently written and competently enough done, but I
found that things flagged badly by half-way and the second half became
something of a slog. There is a lot of
description of the area, an awful lot of detailed (often quoted) political
writing which may have influenced Willy and so on, which eventually seemed
designed to show off how much research Read had done rather than to enhance the
book. I wasn't convinced by the
motivations or relationships which developed, there is some rather lazy
stereotyping of an American visitor (and some unpleasantly misogynistic writing
about her body which seemed to me to come from the author, not just his
characters), a somewhat implausible climax and so on.
Also, given some of the content, have to question the taste
of reissuing this book after Savile, Operation Yew Tree and all that has
emerged in the last decade. I fully
accept that books are of their time and I wouldn't wish to suppress it in any
way, but I do wonder about the decision actively to revive and market it.
So, a disappointment for me, I'm afraid, and I won't be
returning to Piers Paul Read.
(I received an ARC via Netgalley.)
No comments:
Post a Comment